Write a Blog >>
ICSE 2020
Wed 24 June - Thu 16 July 2020
Thu 9 Jul 2020 01:45 - 01:57 at Silla - P18-Open Source Systems Chair(s): John Grundy

Large-scale open source communities, such as the Linux kernel, have gone through decades of development, substantially growing in scale and complexity. In the traditional workflow, maintainers serve as ``gatekeepers'' for the subsystems that they maintain. As the number of patches and authors significantly increases, maintainers come under considerable pressure and that may hinder the operation and even the sustainability of the community. A few subsystems have begun to use new workflows to address these issues. However, it is unclear to what extent these new workflows are successful, nor what factors are critical to their implementation. Therefore, we conduct an empirical study on the multiple-committer model (MCM) that has provoked extensive discussion in the Linux kernel community. We explore the effect of the model on the i915 subsystem with respect to four dimensions: pressure, latency, complexity, and quality assurance. We find that after this model was adopted, the burden of the i915 maintainers was significantly reduced and also, the model scales well to allow more committers. We propose that overloaded subsystems having trustworthy candidate committers are suitable for adopting this model. We further suggest its success is closely related to a series of measures for risk mitigation—sufficient pre-commit testing, strict review process, and the use of tools to simplify work and reduce errors. We employ a network analysis approach to locate candidate committers for the target subsystems and validate this approach and contextual success factors through email interviews with their maintainers. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study focusing on how to scale open source communities. We expect that our study will help the rapidly growing Linux kernel and other similar communities to adapt to changes and remain sustainable.

Thu 9 Jul
Times are displayed in time zone: (UTC) Coordinated Universal Time change

01:05 - 02:05: Paper Presentations - P18-Open Source Systems at Silla
Chair(s): John GrundyMonash University
icse-2020-Journal-First01:05 - 01:13
Yuxia ZhangPeking University, Minghui ZhouPeking University, Audris MockusUniversity of Tennessee - Knoxville, Zhi JinPeking University
icse-2020-Journal-First01:13 - 01:21
Pavneet Singh KochharMicrosoft, Eirini KalliamvakouUniversity of Victoria, Nachiappan NagappanMicrosoft Research, Thomas ZimmermannMicrosoft Research, Christian BirdMicrosoft Research
Pre-print Media Attached
icse-2020-papers01:21 - 01:33
Yuxia ZhangPeking University, Minghui ZhouPeking University, Klaas-Jan StolUniversity College Cork and Lero, Ireland, Jianyu WuPeking University, Zhi JinPeking University
icse-2020-papers01:33 - 01:45
Cassandra OverneyOlin College of Engineering, Jens MeinickeCarnegie Mellon University, Christian KästnerCarnegie Mellon University, Bogdan VasilescuCarnegie Mellon University
icse-2020-papers01:45 - 01:57
Xin TanPeking University, Minghui ZhouPeking University, Brian FitzgeraldLero - The Irish Software Research Centre and University of Limerick